Skies deep gray with the promise of rain ushered me into Lawrenceville on a Sunday afternoon. I was going to Arsenal Bowl on Butler Street; I’d never been, and I had no idea what to expect. Entering the side door and going up the steps, it was like I’d entered someone’s half-remembered dream of a bowling alley from seventy years ago. Wood wall paneling, dim corners, burgundy carpet everywhere—all of it intentional and tasteful to boot. I was directed by an employee deeper into the heart of this puzzling layout. Behind the main hall was a separate, smaller series of alleys, and beyond them was a wall of windows revealing a bar in the back of the building. Coming around and into the quiet barroom, I met Velvet Overkill – Pittsburgh’s premier ‘darkgaze,’ ‘doomnoise,’ ‘grimpunk’ band—and my DEJA contemporaries preparing them for a Twin Peaks-themed photoshoot.

I sat back in an ocean blue suede chair and watched the conducting of the photoshoot in wonder; all so far out of my depth. After the shoot wrapped up, the band met me in the back of the lounge, all four members on a finely embroidered baroque sofa and I on a cushy Ottoman. I powered on my mic and began our discourse.

For the uninitiated, Velvet Overkill formed when Anusha Thompson left the band Street Prophets and joined up with Jared Anderson, Ethan Herring (both formerly of Valleyview) and Joel Warchol (of James Castle) to start what was to be an eggpunk band. By playing together, they naturally shifted into a sound far heavier than eggpunk, to none of their dismay.

“Fun fact, me and Joel were living together at the time; we originally, even before the eggpunk thing, we wanted to start a Skramz band, which is like the exact opposite of what we play now.”
◆ — Jared Anderson, rhythm guitarist

“There were a lot of ideas of what we could be sonically, and then it became this”
◆ — Joel Warchol, drummer

“I feel like you can’t set out to be a specific genre. You just have to kinda see what you make together from personalities. And Ethan—he just wanted to be in a band where he played guitar because he wanted to learn guitar… Ethan was doing bass in Valleyview; he’s a very, very good bassist. He wrote some of the basslines in our songs.”
◆ — Anusha, lead vocalist and bassist

The band has found itself in a season of change these last few months. In June, after returning from touring with fellow Pittsburgh-based band James Castle, Velvet Overkill sent off beloved lead guitarist Ethan Herring with a final show at Club Cafe. Since then, they’ve been laying low and recording their EP.

“We lost our boy Ethan Herring because he moved to Colorado—God bless—so that’s kind of another reason that we took a break, to realign after the loss of our dear friend."
◆ — Joel

Following Ethan’s departure, Adam Smith of solo project Adam’s Purse and Valleyview was brought into the band as a full-time member in Ethan’s place, marking the band’s most major development in recent months.

“I’m pretty new here—so along with all these other things they’ve [the band] been handling, they’ve also been integrating me and getting me caught up with the band material… I feel like we haven’t played too many shows with me, but I feel confident with the material, and I’m happy to honor Ethan’s legacy.”
◆ — Adam, lead guitarist

“Adam’s played with us before, even when Ethan was in the band—so it wasn’t really a matter of teaching him anything. He kinda already knew the songs, which was the primary reason I chose him in the first place.”
◆ — Jared

“Adam is our dear friend, so it’s nothing too new. We don’t have to get used to playing together or anything. It’s like he’s always there.”
◆ — Anusha

“Adam is the John Paul Jones of the Pittsburgh music scene; he does it all and more.”
◆ — Joel

Last year, with the aid of Dylan and Mitch from Dizzier, Velvet Overkill recorded and released two singles – “Manila Folders” and “Plan Voisin”—marking their streaming debut. Now they’re recording the rest of their set on 8-track tape.

“Jack Praksti of James Castle, he’s our engineer, so we do our sessions with him, and he knows everything about that 8-track, it’s incredible,” says Anusha. “It’s been a really comfortable but also slow and tedious process, because it’s a tape and you can’t just punch-in and punch-out so easily and things like that. We’re kind of getting to the vocal part now, finally. It’s been a really cool experience because it sounds so good and it’s not even mixed – it’s just the raw cuts of everything, and it’s like we could release that if we wanted to – it sounds so cool.”

Before Ethan’s departure, Velvet Overkill and James Castle teamed up for a four-stop tour in June—playing in Binghamton, Philadelphia, Baltimore, and Brooklyn. These locations provided a unique traveling system for the band, as they used Ethan’s family farm in Eastern Pennsylvania as a central hub they could return to after every show.

“That was kind of our station, like an hour from Philly,” says Joel, “and then we went to each spot from the farm. Coming back and having breakfast in the morning was really good.”

“We essentially got to live the life of humble farmers while we were going on the road at the same time,” adds Jared, “It was nice at the same time because it was the last time we were spending a significant amount of time with Ethan. It was like a week-long vacation with Ethan and his family where we were also getting to play shows at night.”

“Jared loved to chase his goats,” says Anusha, “Jared’s just chasing the goat all around, and Ethan’s mom let me ride her horse with her! It was so cool. I love horseys, and I don’t get to ride often, but she pulled her retired horse out of retirement just so I could ride him, so shout out to her. They cooked us breakfast and dinner; yeah, we were pretty spoiled.”

Velvet Overkill had yet to play outside Pittsburgh until this tour; they shared some of their favorable aspects of playing in parts unknown.

“Favorite show might’ve been Philly at Dead Bird’s,” says Joel to nods of agreement from the others, “Hosted by Naked Lightbulb and Fuck It We Paul. It was really cool, that was a basement show and we always love basement shows. Everybody’s friends in the two bands [Velvet Overkill and James Castle], so it was a very natural kind of amalgamation to have us go together and kill two birds with one stone because I was able to be in both bands.”

“It was very fun, it was Velvet Overkill’s first time playing out of town,” says Anusha, “It was an amazing experience, and I wish we could do it more often, but yeah, it was really awesome to be received so well in all the cities that we went to. Philly and Binghamton were the best – Binghamton was surprisingly very awesome; I just say that because I haven’t been there or heard of their scene, but it was really fun.”

Since the beginning of 2026, the Pittsburgh music scene has run upon some dry ground. The past year has seen the loss of several popular music institutions such as Haven, Hammerhouse, and Kame House. Where once there were basement shows every Friday night and DJ sets with lines around the block, there are now quiet Oakland streets – like these places never existed at all. The scene is weakened now, but not dead yet.

“I think the biggest issue right now is that not a lot of people have DIY spaces, and I feel like that’s the biggest thing that keeps stuff like this alive,” says Jared, “A lot of the venues around the city, I personally don’t have a lot of fondness for. There’s the Government Center, which I feel is very good – mostly because the people that book the shows there, they know a lot about underground music. I feel like they bring together the community in a very good way. I think bands like Populator and Velvet Overkill, we like to focus on things like the Bloomfield Bridge because it’s something more fun than to just go to the same place and see the same things that you’ve been seeing all the time. The biggest thing that needs to happen is there needs to be more DIY spaces… especially after Anusha’s-led Hammer House disbanded – I think that [Hammer House] was one of the best things that happened to the music scene in the city in a very long time. I feel like if anyone takes anything away from this, it should be to open up a house venue in their basement – like right now.”

“I’d say the best kind of underground scene we have right now is still just the noise scene – like ambient and noise,” adds Joel, “We’re starting to see some really good stuff with even the rave scene a little bit, but right now we’re in a tough spot with the rock bands, so that’s what we need more of.”

“I can think of maybe two or three [DIY venues] off the top of my head, like Hippo House and The Station,” says Anusha, “We loved playing there, those were the more recent DIY spaces that we’ve done, just because that’s all that’s left, which really sucks. I do see more DIY kinda things happening, like what Joel said with the rave scene and noise, which is really awesome, but for rock bands it’s a little sad, it’s so scarce right now. But I really love the Government Center, I think they’ve got the best thing going on right now that’s not DIY.”

Knowing the nature of the band – being musicians all in or from other projects, as well as Anusha’s involvement in Hammer House – it comes as no surprise at all that they’ve made friends with a great many of Pittsburgh’s bands. After a positive experience touring with James Castle, they list some other bands they’d like to tour with.

“Sorryface,” Joel says plainly to unanimous agreement.

“I love Gina Gory,” says Anusha, “They’re such cool people and good buddies of ours, and I think that would also be very similar to like touring with James Castle, but it would also be nice to be around more women on the tour, because I was the only girl with James Castle. I think with them we’d probably have so much fun.”

“I can’t forget Forty Winks,” Anusha says in addition, “That would also be really fun. I’m their new bassist and singer too, so it would be a good mashup; they’re really fun guys.”

Listening to music during the corresponding season can be a highly gratifying experience, and there is no more appropriate time to listen to Velvet Overkill than Autumn. Or maybe searching a town for your dead wife – or searching a town for a teen girl’s murderer. Maybe they’ve pioneered a new genre, Searchcore? Townpunk? Regardless, the band is preparing for Autumn.

“I just recently got a job as an EMT at Kennywood,” says Joel, “Kind of a weird feeling to walk around Kennywood like every weekend all night and look at it from an outside perspective. It’s almost too much of an inside perspective that it makes you feel outside of it. But I love fall-time aesthetics, so I’m fully ingrained – just deep in there. I’m on the front lines of the Halloween fest.”

“My current studio situation, which is also my bedroom, is on the third floor of my house,” says Adam, “It gets really hot up there, so I think as it cools down I’ll become more productive because I’m not sweating out in the oven of my room, so I’m looking forward to that.”

Unbeknownst to me, Joel harbors a treasure trove of Halloween decoration information, and he graciously imparted some useful tips to us.

“Blow molds are coming back into fashion, kind of like the big puffy plastic pumpkins and ghosts and stuff. I’m seeing the inflation in price as well, which is not the best, but they do have good ones at Boscov’s. They had some okay ones at Target – Facebook Marketplace, not the best place to get blow molds right now; they’re definitely price gouging, but if your parents have any stuck up in the attic, you could either make a pretty penny or you could really light up your Fall and Halloween nights,” he says.

As our time was wrapping up, the band reiterated the importance of DIY and the music scene right now. In the ever increasingly sterile corporate climate Pittsburgh is shifting into, nobody else is coming to dig us out.

“I wanna go back to what Jared said earlier,” says Anusha, “Guys, you gotta just set up your basement and do something fun. I don’t have a basement anymore, otherwise, I’d do it. I would bring it back. Even just like one or two shows, like a Halloween show, like fuck it, c’mon… and everybody will love you! But also you’ll make so many friends, that was my favorite part.”

“Reach out to a couple Pittsburgh bands, get something going. People love sensationalist shit,” adds Joel.

“It’s about friendship. I made all my friends doing Hammerhouse, and I’d do it all again… if your landlord doesn’t know and you take precautions, you’ll be fine,” Anusha continues.

You can almost taste it in the air these days. New school year, new students, the promise in Autumn nights, the potential. The city is getting hungry, and the corpo-slop will no longer suffice. We’ve always been a city built on authenticity – when the bars are replaced or bought out by conglomerates and blocks are conquered by foreign property firms – when the city “supports cultural infrastructure” by signing contracts with developers to further bulldoze the Hill District and North Shore to build new charlatanic monoliths – when does Pittsburgh no longer become Pittsburgh? We’re living on the Ship of Theseus in real time, folks. We probably can’t stop what’s coming, but do you want to exercise your agency while you still can? Take Adam Smith’s advice.

“Be creative, be sensitive, and let us in your basement.”

DirectionMarlee Sinagra
ProductionLilly Kubit, Meagan Crough